|
NEW YORK – May 15, 2008
Courting The Wealthy Woman
She's educated, employed, and she controls the lion's share of spending in wealthy
households. Nine out of ten times she is married, or living with a life partner. Her
responsibilities often include working at a high-paying job or running her own business
while also caring for a child or a parent—and managing the household and its finances.
This is the portrait of today's frenetic and financially powerful wealthy woman that
emerges from a recent Luxury Institute survey of women from households with $150,000
or more in annual income ($262,000 average income, $2.2 million average net worth).
Among the key findings is how profound the female influence is on spending and money
management – something that companies from financial firms to home improvement
retailers simply cannot afford to ignore. Married wealthy women, on average, make
almost two-thirds (64 percent) of a family's purchase decisions; 73 percent report making
a majority of the household spending decisions. Almost one in four married wealthy
women (22 percent) say that they make all of the investment decisions on their own;
another two-thirds report making financial decisions jointly with a spouse or partner.
Nearly half (48 percent) say that they call the shots on home improvement projects and
related purchases.
Women hold particular sway at home when it comes to spending money on travel and
home appliances. In more than two-thirds (68 percent) of wealthy households, the
matriarch holds ultimate 'veto' authority on home appliance purchases, making it
extremely difficult to sell ovens, refrigerators or dishwashers to the wealthy without the
consent of the lady of the house. Similarly in travel, 61 percent of wealthy women make
the family's vacation decisions, a powerful swath of authority that includes choice of
destination, airline, hotel, cruise line, car rental, and restaurants. In 48 percent of wealthy
households, women choose the family's health care providers—both the insurance plan
and specific doctors. Bank account selection is the domain of women in 46 percent of
wealthy households; in 40 percent, the woman decides which automobiles and consumer
electronics to buy. Almost one-third of wealthy women (31 percent) say that they control
their family's real estate purchase decisions.
It's often her own money that she's spending and investing. Highly paid females are
flexing financial muscle and turning traditional assumptions about gender and income
roles upside down. On average, women earn 39 percent of the total income in wealthy
households; 24 percent of wealthy women report that they are their family's primary
breadwinner, bringing home at least half of the family's income. Thirteen percent of
wealthy women with a spouse or partner say that they earn at least 70 percent of their
household's total income. These are not women who need to ask permission before
buying something big.
Vol. 104, No. 5
2
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
Wealthy Women At Work
Wealthy women are certainly no idlers: 72 percent work on at least a part-time basis and
54 percent work full-time. Most are well compensated for their efforts: 60 percent of
wealthy women who work earn at least $100,000 a year; 20 percent earn at least
$200,000 and the median annual income of working wealthy women is $124,000. Onethird
of these women (and 45 percent from households with income greater than
$300,000) support another family member through their work; 28 percent support two
family members, and 18 percent support three or more dependents. The average amount
spent on supporting additional family members: $22,400.
The financial influence of affluent females is powerful and growing in the business
world, with women increasingly holding positions of executive authority. One-third of
working wealthy women hold jobs at the vice-president level or higher and another 22
percent hold some type of managerial position. Twelve percent of wealthy women serve
on a company's board of directors; eight percent are partners in a firm; and two percent
hold C-level corporate positions.
Fifteen percent of wealthy women own their own businesses, and lifestyle is a primary
consideration in doing so. One-third say that they launched a business to have a more
flexible schedule, and nine percent did so to be able to spend more time with family and
friends. One in six wealthy women who started a business did so to pursue financial
independence or to take advantage of a better opportunity than they had in their previous
work. Women 55 and older, as well as those with household income greater than
$300,000, are 50 percent more likely to be business owners. Just four percent of women
from high-income households with a net worth less than $1 million, and 10 percent who
are younger than 45 years of age, are entrepreneurs.
Educational attainment helps to explain the financial success of wealthy women. This is
an overwhelmingly college-educated group, with 88 percent of wealthy women holding
at least a bachelor's degree. Overall in the U.S. population, just 26 percent of women
(and 29 percent of men) have earned a bachelor's degree. Twenty-eight percent of
wealthy women have earned a master's degree; another seven percent have an M.B.A.,
and 10 percent have received more advanced degrees. The rate of women with a college
degree rises to 92 percent in households with a net worth of at least $1 million, and to 95
percent for women from households with income between $200,000 and $300,000. For
two decades, women have been outpacing men in earning college degrees—women took
58 percent of all bachelor's degrees awarded in the United States in 2004—so the
accompanying financial achievements of women should continue to grow both on an
absolute level and relative to the earnings of men.
Wealthy Women At Home
Despite their significant financial and professional accomplishments in the workplace,
wealthy women are still far more likely than men to do most of the domestic chores.
Working wealthy women with a husband or partner report that they spend an average of
2.7 hours per day taking care of their household. Almost one in four (22 percent) wealthy
women who work say that they spend at least four hours daily on household duties.
3
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
Meanwhile, nine percent of these working wealthy women report that their spouse has no
household duties, and another 35 percent say that the spouse spends less than an hour a
day on domestic work.
Motherhood may be a big reason for the focus on domestic duties. Seventy-five percent
of wealthy women are mothers—66 percent of those younger than 45 years of age and 81
percent of those who are 55 and older. Just 34 percent, however, have children younger
than 18 living at home. The average number of children is 1.8, with 36 percent of wealthy
women the mother of two children, 12 percent with three, and 12 percent with a brood of
four or more.
Wealthy Women In The Marketplace
Among the businesses with the most to gain from a sharper female focus are brokers and
banks. Women cite their financial situation more frequently—39 percent of the time—
than anything else when asked for one area of their lives that they would most like to
improve. Credit card companies are apparently meeting this need, with 33 percent of
wealthy women saying that credit card providers do the best job of any industry
marketing to women. Only hotels (48 percent) ranked higher. Brokers, however, have
some ground to cover: just six percent of wealthy women say that brokerages are doing
the best job marketing their services to them. Just one in ten mention private banks or
commercial banks as being supreme in their marketing to wealthy women; 13 percent
mention insurance companies.
Home improvement chains, realtors, and car companies get the message from wealthy
women—and in turn they're getting their messages across effectively. Nearly one in four
wealthy women say that these industries do a superb job of marketing to women.
Marketing by private jet companies (three percent), liquor brands and electronics brands
(both eight percent) fails to resonate in large numbers with wealthy women. One idea
may be to "go green": 60 percent of wealthy women say that they prefer using a
company's products or services if they operate by socially or environmentally sound
business practices.
Marriott, Hilton, Visa and Home Depot stand out for their skill in marketing to wealthy
women. Each of these companies earned an unaided mention from seven percent of
respondents. American Express (five percent) and Remax (four percent) each received
frequent mention, as did Cadillac, Capital One, Lowe's and Westin (each with three
percent). Honing the proper message for wealthy female consumers starts with
understanding their needs and tastes, followed by creating relevant products and services
that are delivered with impeccable service—just good fundamentals of business.
Luxury Lust: A Biological Link?
Higher social status has long been known to correlate with better health, but it now
appears that even perceived changes in status are enough to trigger physiological
reactions. Researchers at the National Institute of Mental Health identified specific
changes in brain activity in students competing in a computer game for money when told
how their performance stacked up against inferior and superior players. Outperforming
the better player—even though there was none—activated areas in the brain controlling
4
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
action planning; underperforming an inferior "player" activated areas associated with
emotional pain and frustration. The results of the research in the April 24, 2008, issue of
the journal Neuron may also provide some physiological basis for the human desire to
buy luxury goods and services to elevate or reinforce their social status.
Luxury Automobiles –Brand Status
Porsche races ahead of Lexus and Mercedes to take the top spot for status among luxury
nameplates. In a recent Luxury Institute Luxury Brand Status Index (LBSI) survey of
luxury automobile brands, wealthy consumers ranked Porsche highest for overall brand
status. Respondents cite the German carmaker's "reputation for performance" and call
Porsche automobiles "world-class sports cars for the true connoisseur." Those surveyed
have an average household income of $349,000 and average net worth of $3.7 million.
Wealth Management – Brand Status
The poor risk management practices on display at many large financial firms over the
past year have not gone unnoticed by these same banks' existing and potential wealth
management clients. Recognizing that wealth management firms faced a likely crisis of
credibility with clients in the wake of the subprime meltdown and the ensuing credit
crunch, the Luxury Institute surveyed an elite panel of ultra-wealthy American investors
($751,000 average income, $13.9 million average net worth) to gauge the impact of risk
mismanagement on brand status. No large financial firm will emerge from the crisis
without some scars, but those that have done a better job than others in managing their
exposure can boost their image in the eyes of wealthy clients. Now is the time for firms
to assess any damage to their brand reputations and to take action to earn back the
damaged trust and confidence of wealthy investors. Here are the Wealth Management
LBSI standouts, ranked by wealthy investors and grouped by type of institution:
Private Banks: Northern Trust maintains its reputation and earns the highest LBSI
ranking in the private banking category. Goldman Sachs, a firm that actually profited for
a time from the mortgage meltdown, earns a number two ranking, and J.P. Morgan
Private Bank ranks third. Pleased clients say that Northern Trust is "well-established" and
that it has "been focused on wealth management for a long time." In contrast, Bear
Stearns, the troubled firm that JP Morgan agreed to buy in March, scored a record low
3.49 out of 10—a clear reflection of Bear Stearns' seemingly reckless financial practices
that sent the firm into insolvency and to the brink of bankruptcy before the Federal
Reserve's rescue plan that included a fire-sale to JP Morgan.
Commercial Banks: JP Morgan Private Client Services takes top honors for brand
status. Ranking behind JP Morgan in second and third places, respectively: Wachovia
Wealth Management and Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management.
Regional Banks: Based in Winston-Salem, N.C., BB&T Wealth Management earns the
highest LBSI among regional bank wealth managers. Pittsburgh-based PNC Wealth
Management (formerly PNC Advisors) earns second place in the regional bank rankings,
and Chicago's LaSalle Bank Wealth Management comes in third. The category overall,
has taken a substantial hit in status. In 2007, the average LBSI score for a firm was 6.56,
but that slipped nearly a full index point to 5.60.
5
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
Accounting Firms – Brand Status
Wealthy consumers rank the PricewaterhouseCoopers brand tops for prestige in the
accounting profession. Because high net worth consumers are likely to employ
accounting firms for both business and personal affairs, it logically follows that wealthy
individuals will have some familiarity with firms in this field. PricewaterhouseCoopers
clients call the firm "thorough, professional and capable" with "high quality and
integrity." Tied for second place: Deloitte & Touche and Ernst & Young.
Individual Excellence in Luxury Leadership – Financial Services
Charles E. Williamson is president of AIG Private Client Group, a provider of high-end
property and liability insurance to wealthy individuals and families. He assumed his
current duties in January of 2006, but has been with American International Group, Inc.,
since 1988, serving in several leadership capacities. He was senior vice president of sales
and marketing for the domestic brokerage group, executive vice president of the excess
casualty unit of AIG's American Home Assurance Company, and senior vice president of
casualty for AIG Risk Management. Williamson is a graduate of Marshall University and
holds a J.D. from St. John's University.
WR: Share with us the evolution of your career and the critical steps to your role today.
Charles E. Williamson : Over the years I served in a variety of managerial roles. Despite
the different areas of focus, the corporate culture has remained consistent. AIG really
embraces ingenuity and ambition, and I've been fortunate to learn from some of the best
and brightest in the field. It wasn't until I transitioned to an executive role that I realized
how valuable this diversity was. AIG Private Client Group is only in its eighth year of
business, but drawing on my prior experience has helped us go from being the new kid on
the block to the thought leader in our space.
How has the concept of luxury evolved during your career, and how does its definition
affect your clients?
AIG Private Client Group’s business model focuses on the needs of our customers — not
on the products we sell. So for us, the concept of "luxury" has remained consistent. What
has evolved is our understanding of the end customer. Learning more about them helps us
continue to serve them successfully. For example, research has shown that the vast
majority of wealthy individuals in the U.S. have become wealthy through career success.
The "entrepreneur" has essentially replaced the "heir" as the client. Today’s millionaires,
or even billionaires, often retain their middle-class values. In fact, they don't necessarily
think of themselves as "rich." That attitudinal shift impacts our overall marketing efforts.
Based on your experiences, what are the critical factors that luxury brands need to know
to create great customer experience for high net worth consumers?
It's critical to anticipate the needs of your customers based on their evolving lifestyles.
Identifying unaddressed problems—and devising solutions—not only keeps you in a
leadership position, but also it can create shifts in the market as a whole. AIG Private
Client Group has created quite a few products and services that simply did not exist
before we entered the market. For example, we offer a suite of services to help
6
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
policyholders dramatically reduce the likelihood of property damage due to natural
disasters such as wildfires and hurricanes. Our competitors have followed our lead in
some instances, but that only helps consumers in the long run.
There is one other factor I'd like to mention. Unlike retail products, insurance is
intangible. Superior customer service, therefore, is paramount—particularly at claim
time. Our claims professionals get personally involved to ensure that a policyholder's
individual preferences are considered every step of the way. Our creativity and hands-on
support receives constant praise from our customers, which is extremely gratifying. In
addition, AIG Private Client Group can only be accessed through independent insurance
brokers. They serve as the "face" of our business, so we only work with a small
percentage of the broker community. We want to make sure those who represent us
espouse our same values.
What have you found to be the critical skills and attributes that luxury executives need to
develop to lead their companies?
I have a relentless drive to innovate, and I've tried to impress that upon our staff. As I
mentioned earlier, we always need to consider the changing needs of our customers.
Equally important, however, is to surround yourself with the best people and to give them
the freedom to thrive. We have a great example within AIG Private Client Group. A few
years ago, one of our risk managers recognized the efficacy of the fire retardant used by
the U.S. Forest Service and thought, "Wouldn't it be great to protect individual homes
with that same technology?" His inventive idea led us to create our Wildfire Protection
Unit, a complimentary service for our policyholders in high-risk parts of California and
Colorado. And incidentally, that risk manager is now the service director.
What has been one major challenge in your career and how did you overcome it?
At first, it was challenging to make the transition from commercial insurance to personal
insurance. I generally went from serving Fortune 500 companies to Forbes 400
individuals, and I needed quickly to understand new issues and opportunities for growth.
I was able to overcome the challenge by realizing a common thread: the need to devise
customized solutions for powerful buyers. With that in mind, I could navigate a new
business by drawing upon everything I'd learned throughout my career.
Luxury Retail Outlook
Retail sales continue to come in weak at the high-end of the market. Retailers overall
posted a deceptively decent gain of 3.6 percent in April sales at stores open at least a
year, according to the UBS-International Council of Shopping Centers retail sales tally.
The timing of Easter, however, makes year-over-year comparisons difficult. Luxury
retail continued to take its lumps. Nordstrom, for example, reported a 3.8 percent samestore
sales decline.
Retailers can take little comfort in the attitudes the wealthiest 10 percent—11.2 million—
of U.S. households. This group—with a minimum net worth of $828,000—has a much
more favorable view of the economy 12 months from now than it does of the present
situation, but plans for spending are muted. According to the American Affluence
Research Center's Affluent Market Tracking Survey #13, the index of future business
7
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
conditions is 99, and while not optimistic, is almost double the current index reading of
52. Also, there is more optimism than pessimism within this ultra-wealthy group on the
outlook for the stock market and for their own income 12 months from now. Optimism,
as a rule, rises with income and wealth. Vacation travel, however, is the only luxury
spending category projected by AARC to experience growth in the next 12 months, and
55 percent of the ultra-wealthy report making a conscious effort to defer or reduce
expenditures. The tendency to cut back recedes predictably as wealth escalates: just onethird
of individuals worth $6 million or more are making any efforts to slow down their
spending.
Luxury firms are turning to sales outside of the United States and Western Europe to fuel
their growth, resulting in a potentially enduring sea change in luxury consumption.
Russia, Brazil, India and especially China are becoming important areas for sustained
future growth for luxury goods firms, and their value is also apparent more immediately
as they take up slack for slumping U.S. and European economies. China, the third largest
consumer of luxury goods globally with a 12-percent market share, could jump ahead of
the U.S. this year and be second only to Japan in consumption of luxury gods. The latest
call for the surge in Chinese luxury sales comes from Wang Depei, vice chairman of the
China Economic System Reform Research Association at the First Luxury Brands Forum
in Shanghai. Depei forecasts that China will overtake Japan in luxury consumption by
2015.
The Globalization of Talent
As luxury firms expand into new markets and as new firms are created to tap into
opportunities around the world, the need to find executive talent to manage the business
in multiple countries is often an impediment to expansion. Smart executive search firms
understand the need for talent on-demand and they're capitalizing on the boom in global
trade. New York-based Martens & Heads! fulfills domestic, global and online needs of
image-driven brands in fashion, luxury, and beauty industries. Through representatives in
Paris and Hong Kong, the search firm casts a global net for talent to ensure chemistry and
cultural fit for executives who bring expertise in strategy, branding and the global
marketplace. Visit www.maxinemartens.com for details on their global network of talent.
8
Your use of a Luxury Institute or Luxury Board document constitutes your agreement to (i) use the content under a
limited license only for your own internal purposes, and (ii) not disclose, publish or otherwise make public or provide
the content, in whole or in part, to any third person or entity without the prior written consent of The Luxury Institute,
LLC. The content is and remains at all times the exclusive intellectual property of The Luxury Institute, LLC.
Copyright © 2008 The Luxury Institute, LLC. Published by The Luxury Institute, LLC, 115 E 57th St, 11th Fl, NY, NY 10022
|